Bay Shore, NY Investor Insights

Real estate investment activity and market trends in Bay Shore, NY, New York

1,670 active investors · 301 acquisitions (last 12 mo)

Data as of May 2026 · Updated monthly

Active Investors1,670ilast 12 mo
Avg Acquisition$521Kilast 12 mo
Rental Yield8.1%ifrom geo_stats
Acquisitions301ilast 12 mo
Value-Add+55%ipurchase vs value

Most Active Zip Codes in Bay Shore, NY

Zip codes with the most investor activity in Bay Shore, NY

Zip CodeInvestorsAvg PriceYield
117061680$520K8.1%

Recently Active Investors in Bay Shore, NY

Investors with purchases in the last 6 months

#iInvestoriPortfolioiPortfolio ValueiLast PurchaseiLast Addressi
1NAWAL REALTY INCiLong termi234i$11.5Mi2023-07-31i3C105 Hemlock Dr, Bay Shorei
2POINT OF WOODS ASSOCIATIONiLong termi64i$812Ki2022-01-07i49 Center Ave, Bay Shorei
3ZANE SELLIS LLCiLong termi54i$456Ki2020-11-23i1A136 Hemlock Dr, Bay Shorei
4FAMILY RESIDENCES & ESSENTIAL ENTERPRISES INCiLong termi18i$2.9Mi2024-03-22i1046 Joselson Ave, Bay Shorei
5AR RAHMAN 789 INCiLong termi7i$458Ki2024-03-19i5A Hemlock Dr, Bay Shorei

Investor Value Add

✓ Live Data

Avg Purchase

$521K

i

Avg Value

$809K

i
+55%ivalue appreciation

in Bay Shore, NY

Average Rents

✓ Live Data
1 Bedroom$2,610i
2 Bedroom$3,953i
3 Bedroom$4,975i

in Bay Shore, NY

Top Recent Sales in Bay Shore, NY

Transactions by active real estate investors

14 Muncey Rd, Bay Shore

i

$680K

i
ALL STAR PROPERTIES LLCiLong termi· 2026-03-31i

125 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore

i

$540K

i
COLGATE PROPERTY GROUP LLCiLong termi· 2026-02-27i

1039 Joselson Ave, Bay Shore

i

$625K

i
ATLANTIC SHRS PROP BU INCiLong termi· 2026-02-13i

14 Mystic Cir, Bay Shore

i

$650K

i
COOL BREEZE PROPERTIES II LLCiLong termi· 2026-02-12i

1358 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore

i

$650K

i
3 WELLWOOD AVENUE CORPiLong termi· 2026-02-10i

Active in Bay Shore, NY?

Close your next deal in Bay Shore, NY with a LendingOne DSCR or bridge loan.

Get a DSCR Loan

Free Market Report: Bay Shore, NY

Get rental comps, investor activity, and DSCR data for your target area.

No spam. A loan advisor may reach out with relevant opportunities.